Plan Bd. OKs Extension For Lot Sale, Subdivision Bid

For The Leader/Times

SCOTCH PLAINS — With no applications on its agenda, the planning board this week granted a developer 30-day extension to file subdivision plans for a property on Hill Road.

Cardamone Brothers Custom Homes is in the process of purchasing the lot at 2311 Hill Road, where an 80-year-old single-family house presently stands, with the intention of subdividing it in order to build new homes. The company is in negotiations with the property owners, Robert and Diane Coloney, but the builder claimed the process has been delayed by Covid-19-related shutdowns.

At the board’s June 22 meeting, the company requested a 190-day extension to complete the details of the purchase. Planning Board Attorney Robert Pansulla, noting the “emergency situation” stemming from the pandemic, told the board he saw no problem with granting the extension. Cardamone Brothers’ attorney, Lisa Lomelo, said there was “ample reason” for the board to grant the extension.

But Donald Fraser, the attorney for the Coloneys, objected to the 190-day request, saying it would be used to “unduly delay the purchase” and claiming the buyers would use the additional six months as leverage over the Coloneys. He said he favored extending the time to the end of July.

“Nobody is hurt if the board does a 30-day extension,” Mr. Fraser said as he reiterated his claim that a 190-day extension would “unduly and unfairly prejudice” the Coloneys.

He also complained that the buyers “did not bother” to inform him or his clients about the need for additional time but that he had found out about it “secondhand.”

After a brief discussion, the board voted unanimously to extend the time to complete the sale and subdivision application to Friday, July 31. Chairman Joseph Doyle said he felt that an additional 190 days was “not as necessary” as the Cardamone Brothers’ attorney had claimed. Vice-Chairman Jeffrey Strauss agreed, saying the 190-day request “was a lot” and adding that a July 31 deadline gives the parties time to work out their differences and come to an agreement.

To view more stories like this, please SUBSCRIBE.